نړيوال ښکيلاک او د لرو بر افغان دازادۍ غورځنګ

يو ډېر خوندور/ خندور ديالوګ !

pattang
05.09.2010

يو ډېر خوندور/ خندور ديالوګ !

Iliasjan, salam
Man khosh astam ki ba masael watan ba een had alaqa dared. Tamam nawishtai shoma sawalat bar angeez ast, ki ba har yek bayad jawab gofta shawad. Ba tawri namoona:
Shoma dar haliki gela dared ki hama hokomathai gozashat Pashtun bodand, zalim bodand wa degran ra az hoqoqi shan mahroom karda bodand. wali baz megoeed ki dar daulat hai sabeq wazir, raees hama ba khateri farsi sobat mekardan chun lessan pashtun ra kasse dar afghanistan as sharm sobat namekard. Chara? Chara? Ham aksariat bashand, ham hokomat wa qodrat dar dastishan bashad, Pas chara ba zabani khod besharmand.
Shoma megoeed ki padari shoma Pashtun ast. Qabool. Wali chera az yek nafar Pashtun een qisim bachai nehayat oqda badil, dar moqabili qawmi padari khod, paeda shoda? Rabitai shoma ba padari bozorgwaritan qabili sawal ast. Aya tarbia zaeef bood wa ya kodam noqsi degar dar mian booda ast. Ta ki een sawali mohim hal nashoda bashad, fikar namikunam kas bitwanad bar masaeli degari tan tabsira konad.
Ehtiram

________________________________________
From: elias-12@hotmail.de
To: farouqazam@hotmail.com
Subject: RE: Salam
Date: Fri, 3 Sep 2010 15:50:27 +0200

Aghai doctor saheb salam,

humid ast ke ramazan mubarak ra ba khubi separi kunend. Sobate shuma ziad aamozishi ast wa feker mekunum ke jagan bar jak janeba ast. khub tarin dostane man wa padaram pashun astand wa maa kheshi ham hamrishan kardeem. Amaa masla in ast ke man emroz dare alman ba name afghan , gardan bur, terrorist, maktab soz, doctor kush wa mahlem kush, sangsar kunenda, zan wa dukhtar ra masmum kunende wa tizab pashende khetab mekunand. man medanum ke in kar kar man, hazara, turkman, tajik neest. pas chera ma hamradif ba wazirestani ha, mardum queta, bajawuli dar jak radif qarar begirum. ke medanad ke in kar ra serf kundam meardum mekunad. fehlan dar afghanistan ham daulat pashtun ast wa ham zed daulat pashtun ast ( karzai, wazir defah wardak, wazir kharja, wazir mahraef, sarhadat ect) hama pashtun. ba khudawan dar in roza qabul kuneed ke pashtun hai afghan dar germany sharm darand ke kudar nazd almani ha pashtun khetab kunand wa megojan ma tajik asteem, chum 99,99% taleb pashtun ast. Lesan farsi lesan sobat mahwera wa takalum baine tamame aqwame afghansitan ast mesle englisi bain digar meliat ha. uzbak hamrai pashtu harosi karda hama ha du farsi sobat mekunand chun pashtun uzsbaki jad nadarad wa uzbak pashtu. 90% mardume afgh agar tajik ham nabashand farsi subat mekunand chun lesan mahwera watan masst, ba aqaliat wa aksariat marbut neest. agar ba aksariat mebud bajad lesan chin wa chinai lesan rassmi dunia meshu. Dar daulat hai sabeq wazir, raees hama ba khateri farsi sobat mekardan chun lessan pashtun ra kasse dar afghanistan as sharm sobat namekard. Dar daftar ha az khatere azara, tajik budand chun hama ba daftar dari, sawat balad budand. pashtun khu hama askari namekardand ama bad az senfe 12 zabet, saheb mansab , general meshudand ke hamada jang bashand. chetur man farda ba pesare khud tashre kunum ke hazara hamesh muzdore saheb mansabe pshtun mebud? chera askari nee ama saheb msaabi bale? chera hama dar kabul musala megashtand, chera chub wa har chiz ra paksitan qachab meburdand. Ba nazare shuma muhatram bain aghai ing. gulbuddin hekmatiar wa general tanai che makhraje mushtarak bud ke jak mushrek wa kommunist mutlaq hamria jak musalam kudata dar zaman najib kunand? tanha lessane pashtu. Asle jang wa qurbani ra bar zede russia ra mardume ke dar sharah kabul wa sarhad russia (Tajikistan) budand dadand. mesle, mardum dushi, salam, jabulesaraj, cherikar, qarabagh. Na mardum panjsher, paktia, paktika, jalaabad, kandahar ja helmand. pas chera 5 milliom farar kardand? magar taraki, afizulag amin, barak karmal, doctor najib pashtun nabudand? az tarse ki raftand paksitan? chera p mardum shenwar jak roz khalqi budand, roze digar pul megerftand, mujahid meshudand, baz taleb meshudan baz duzd wa rahzan. hamesh mardum wa aquam digare afghanistan begana hara az aghanistan mekashand ama mezban in ha hamsh pashzun ha budand. Sha sheja, karmal, taraki. jak zane saqau (malalai) dar jange maiwand deleer wa qaraman mesha chun pashtun bud amaa saqau shamali ke ba mujaheedin waqt aab meburd buzd wa mahrefi shud. duzdan amir dostmohaamd khan jalad, nader ghadar watan forosh baba meshand neka meshand ama digar ha hma duzd.

mardum wa tarikhe afgh baa jak chashem koor astand wa tarikhe maa ghalat ast. man ba ham afgh man eftekhar mekunum, azara, uszbek, tajik wa pashtun ta waqte ke afghan bashand. hama kuchi ha 2 tabiat darand. aksare pashtun hai fehli afgha ke az pakistan astand wa ja az pakistan hamadand 2 shenakhte kard darand, wa kudam delsozi ba afgh nadarand. Marume roshan feker pashtun hama medanand ke asle meshkel afghansitan che ast. 200 sale pesh mulah lang wa ala mulah omar, haqani. Sarnaweshte watan ma ba mardum roshan fekre danda shawad, na ba besawad ha ha asbad daste mardum arab, pamjabi wa kashiri shudand. begzareed ke watan ra ba ham besazim wa az waqiat aa chashem dori nakunem. maa hamesh ba pashtun ha mesle beradar zendagi mekardum am dar zama taleban wahshi jak bar aksar pashtun ke dar manateq shamal zendagi mekardand taleb shudand cheun pashtun budand. aakher cher doctor saheb. haqel, kala, feker, ensaniat, ehsan, mardum dosti hama gum shud. Aghai Ing. saheb gulbudin hekmatiar dar bonn chandi sale qabel gut ke wa awal pashtun ast bad afghan bowoode han ke ing saheb dar kunduz baghlan bozurg shuda.
sare shumara ba dard dar in roz mubarak ramazn ´namehawarum wa shuma bajad jak janeba feker nakuneed. awal ensan budan, watan dosti, liaqat, mohem ast bad lesan samt qa qabela.

khuda hafiz tan wa roze khuish ba shuma aarzo daram.

ba ehteram
________________________________________
From: farouqazam@hotmail.com
To: elias-12@hotmail.de
Subject: RE: Salam
Date: Tue, 31 Aug 2010 13:15:59 +0100

Iliasjani mohtaram
Az namitan tashakur.
Shoma gufta eed ki dawlathai gozasht hama Pashtun boda wa dar statistic dast zada. Shayad. Agar karda bashad kari kharab karda wa heech faida ham nadarad. Motasifana, Haala chineen ast. Dar waqti tajawazi Russia, taqriban 6 million Afghan mohajir shodand. Ki azaan jomla 5 million Pashtun boda, ki 4 million dar Pakistan wa 1 million dar Iran. Haala ki ba watan baz migardand, choon dar daftarha aksaran firsi zabanan moqrarand ba anha tazkirai ki medihad, dar khanai qawmiayat, tajik nawashta mikunnand. Man chandeen entawar tazkirahara deeda am. Hata dar wazarati kharja dar Kabul, doo farsi zaban ra mishnasam ki har do raees astand, yaki tajik wa digar Pashtun. Aan yaki ba khatiri khodra Pashtun nawishta karda ki sahmi Pashtun ra dar wazarat begirad, ki kas nagoyad ki dar wazarati kharija sahmi pashtunha kam ast. Dar aksari wazaratha hameentawar shoda wa ba kharijiha list nishan medihand ki eena pashtunha hamrahi ma astand. Een choneen soyi estifadaha shoda, wali waqiathara ba een tazwir wa fireebha tagheer karda namitwanad. Wa har kas ki een kar mikonad, bad mikonad.
Shoma gofta eed ki hokomati gozashta dar dasti Pashtunha boodand. Bali, choon aksarayat nofoosi Afghanistan ra tashkeel medihand. Dar har jayi donya hameen qism ast. Wali dar Afghanistan hameesh padoshahani Pashtun hokomat ra baa digaran shareek karda bood. Dar hokomati pashtunha dar maktabha ba farsi dars khwanda mishod, daftarha ba farsi boodand, wa tamam karobari dawlat ba zabani farsi bood. Waziran wa karmandani kalani dawlat aksar farsizaban boondand, ki een khod nishan midihad ki shahan Pashtun mikhast ki wahdati milli baja bashad. Dar Kandahar wa Helmand ki markazi Pashtunha ast wa shahani Afghanistan azeenja bodand, ba hazarha khanawar Qizilbash wa Hazara ra eskan karda. Hamchineen dar Ghazni, Paktia, Paktika, Laghman, Jalalabad wa Kunar ba hazarha khanawarTajik tawasuti shahani gozashta eskan shoda.
Shoma nawisha eed ki: “felan dar welaite parwan tazkera serf waqte gerefta metawani, ke qaum khudra pashtun begoie agar hazara ja tajek ham bashi”. Man bisyar tajob mikunam ki dar parwan, wali tajik ast (Abdul Baseer Salangi); Qomandani amniya tajik ast (Faqir Mohammad), Waziri dakhilai Afghanistan (Bismillah Khan) tajik ast; Tajikha dar parwan dar aksariyat ast wa Pashtunha dar aqaliat (yak sowami tamami nofoos). Chara tazkera serf waqte gerefta metawani, ke qaum khudra pashtun begoie agar hazara ja tajek ham bashi. Edai padar bozorgwari shoma shayed neez chonin boda ki qabili gh
Shoma nawishta eed ki: “Ba man qumandan ha muhem neestand, chun tamame mulah wa maulawi ma pashtun ha bundand wa hama baz qumandan shudand”. (1), bayad bogoyam ki qawmi shoma bisyar shareef wa mosolmanhayi khoob astand wa ta’asob nadarand ki mulai khodra pahtun migirand. Mardomi khoob astand. Hamchineen ast dar manatiqi pashtuzaban. Mardomi ma motahid astand. Faqat anani atashi nifaq ra daman mizanand ki nalayeq astand, mazdorani kharijiha boda wa bar qawmi khod tijarati siyasi mikonand ta azeen tareeq nan wa ya qodrat payda konand. (2) heech kas bar qawmi digar qomandani karda namitawanad wa anhara ba marg borda namitawanad. Shoma bayad qawmi khodra tahqeer nakoneed ki yak Pashtun miayad wa hama qawmi shomara poshti sari khod ba beraha mikashanad. shoma migoeed ki mulai shoma pashtunha bodand wa hama baz qomandan shodand. Yani qawmi shoma poshti anha raftand. Ham dar halati solh imamishan bodand wa ham dar halati jang pushti shan raftand. Qawmi shoma bisyar najeeb, mosolman wa watan doost ast wa man namidanam shoma chi moshkil ba qawmi khod dared wa chara dareed?
Shoma migoeed ki: “Dorost ast ke azara az afgh markazi astand, ama felan dar kabul astand. pashtun hai atrafe kabul ham az paktia, laghman, wazirstan ect astand wa kabuli neestand. mardum pashtune pakistan ra bayad ma esab nakunem”. Man istidlali shomara nafahmidam. (1), ba fikri shoma namidanam ki qabl az amadani laghmaniha wa pakistaniha dar dakhil wa atrafi wilayati Kabul ki bodand? Dar digar manatiq az koja amad and? (2), shama Pashtunhai atraf wa dakhili Kabul ra Pakistani migoeed? Shoma tasawar mikoneed ki ba een istidlal bajayi biraseed? Dar Helmand hazarha khanawar Uzbek, Turkmen, wa Hazara eskan shoda, ba goftayi shoma anha haq darand wali bashindagan asliyi aan wilayat Pakistani astand. Agar har kas bogoyad ki filan qawm az koja amada, wa filan az koja amada, chi natija khwaheem girift? Chitor shoda mitawanad ki ba mardomi asliyi Kabul bogoyeem ki shoma azeen khak nessteed wa mardomiki az digar jaha amada kubili astand. Shoma chara mantiqi tanra zaeef misazeed. Shoma Hazara, Panjsheri, Badakhshi,…. ra ki dar kabul felan zindagi mikonand kabuli midaneed wali mardomi asliyi anran khariji midaneed. Een chi mantiq ast. Agar statistic ki kharijeha tarteb karda qabool nashawad, wa agar waqiathai aini wa hakim bar mantiqa rad shawad, pas aya een qisim mantiq ba jai merasad? Aya ba wahdati mili mofeed ast? Eenki yakdigar ra khariji bogoyim chi faeda wa chi mikhwaheem badast biyareem. Agar ma mikhwaheem ki Afghanistan ra joor koneem bayad yak digar ra bipazirim. Agar shoma aksariati momlakat ra pazirofta namitawanid, az anha chi tawaqo dared ki shoma ra bepazirad? Dareen kashmakash ki zarari beshtar khwahad deed? Nabayad ba qawmi khod nafahmida zarar rasand wa doshmani kard.
Shoma migoyid: “Mardum kuchie ha ham afghan astand wa ham Pakistani”. Hech kochi Pakistani neest. Hama afghan astand. Een awaleen dafa ast ki man az shoma mishnawam ki kochihai Pakistan ba Afghanistan mi ayad. Een ikhtira az kuja shoda? Har kas ki ba shoma gofta shomara sada fikar karda. Aya bar har Pashtun bayad tapai Pakistan zada shawad? Ba fikri shoma dar Afghanistan heech pashtun neest. Agar Pashtunha chonin tapa bar shoma bizanad, gap ba koja mirasad? Wa azeen chi joor mishawad?
Shoma nawisha eed ki: “Ama dar bin pashtun hai ma dar Germany awal pashtun budan muhem ast (betafawut inke paksitani ja afghanis), bad musalman budan bad afghan budan. ma kudam chize mushtarak hamrai pashtun queta, bajawur nadareem”. Shoma migoeed ki hama Pashtunhayi ki dar Germany astand, Pakistani astand? Ta’ajob.
Eliasjani qand, ma wa shoma zarorat ba tafahum, fikar wa kari moshtarak darim. Shoma bayad yak rooz ba khod bishineed wa khoob fikar koneed ki chi mikhwaheed badast biyareed? Aya ba hameen istidlal wa fikar hama pashtunhara az Afghanistan gom karda mitwaneed? Az khod bayd porsan bokoni ki to ki degaranran ra qabool karda namitawani, anha shomara chitoor qabool khwahand kard? Natija chi misha, dardi sar, nafrati beshtar, tafroqai beshtar? Agar yak digar ra napazirim, baz goftogo chi?
Maa kishwari bisyar maqbool wa mardomi bisyar shareef dareem. Biyayeed barayi wahdati aan wa tafahom baini Afghanha koshish koneem. Har kas shayad ishtibah karda bashad, wali zindagi mohtaramana dar gozasht, tafahom wa rawadari ast.
Ehtiram

________________________________________
From: elias-12@hotmail.de
To: farouqazam@hotmail.com
Subject: RE: Salam
Date: Mon, 30 Aug 2010 17:22:02 +0200

Doctor saheb muhtaram salam,

tashkur au khate shuma wa az mahlumate zamima tan. Ba man tafawut bine tajik, pashtun, hazara neet. man multiculti astam. ama mekhaham haqiqat ra dar baara watan padaram bedanam wa har mahlumat ba man ziad muhem ast. Nazar ba mahlumate man wa sobate padaram daulat hai guzashte hama pashtun budand wa statistic ra dast zadand. Wa felan dar welaite parwan tazkera serf waqte gerefta metawani, ke qaum khudra pashtun begoie agar hazara ja tajek ham bashi. Ba man qumandan ha muhem neestand, chun tamame mulah wa maulawi ma pashtun ha bundand wa hama baz qumandan shudand. Dorost ast ke azara az afgh markazi astand, ama felan dar kabul astand. pashtun hai atrafe kabul ham az paktia, laghman, wazirstan ect astand wa kabuli neestand. mardum pashtune pakistan ra bajad ma esab nakunem. Mardum kuchie ha ham afghan astand wa ham pakistani. ba man awal muhem ast afghnis budan, musalman budan wa dar qadam aakher tajik budan. man ba iran zaban mushtarak darum, ama az irani khusham nemehaiad wa jak pashtun afgh<ni (na pakistan) ra 100 martaba behtar az tajike tajikestanja farsi zabane irani medanum. Ama dar bin pashtun hai ma dar Germany awal pashtun budan muhem ast (betafawut inke paksitani ja afghanis), bad musalman budan bad afghan budan. ma kudam chize mushtarak hamrai pashtun queta, bajawur nadareem.

khuda hafiz wa waqte khush ba shuma
elias

________________________________________
From: farouqazam@hotmail.com
To: elias-12@hotmail.de
Subject: RE: Salam
Date: Mon, 30 Aug 2010 00:54:38 +0100

Iliasjani mohtaram.
Man az sawalhai shuma khosh mishwam. Elm wa danish ba porsaan haasil mishawad. man ham mota'alim wa shagird astam wa mikhwaham az shoma wa digran biyamozam. Hazrat Ali mefarmayand ki kassi aalim mishawad ki sharm dar rahi kasbi elm nadashta bashad. Wali, porsish nabayad brayi aazar wa lajajat bashad ki rahi choneen kas ba dozakh ast.
Brai jawab swalati shum lotfan b zamimai een namah tawajoh befarmaeed. Raji be Kabul wa Herat sawalati moshakhas karda bodeed ki jawabi shan dar zamiza ast. Kabul ki markazi Afghanistan ast wa hammai maa anra dost dareem, shoma khoob bebineed. Atrafi Shahri Kabul aksariat Pashtun astand. Dar Shamali sharq Deh sabz wa Kohi safi astand ki aksarayti shan Pashtun astand w qomandani shan Mawlawi Shafiulla wa Mawlawid Seddiqullah bodand ki Pashtun bodand. Dar Sharq wa Jonobi sharq Kabul Botkhak wa Khord Kabul ast ki hama Pashtun astand wa qomandanan shan Mia Agha, Eng Afzal, Hakim Khan, Arsala Khan bodand ki hamma Pashtun bodand. Albata dar Dehi chakari tajik ham astand. Dar jonobi kabul Bagrami wa shiwaki wa khairabad wa char Aasia astand ki aksaryat bozorg shan Pashtun Astand ki aksar dar dasti qomandanani Pashtun bodand. Albata dar dehi Qomori chand khana tajik ham ast. Dar jonobi gharb wa gharb chonghar wa madan ast ki aksarat Pashtun ast wa qomandan shan Toran Amanullah bood ki Pashtun bood. Dar gharbi Kabul Paghman ki aksariyat pashtun hastand wali tajikha ham hastand. qomandanai shan Ustad sayyaf, Haji sher Alam bodand ki pashtun hastand. Dar shamali gharbi kabul (karizmir, estalif, shakardara) hardo qawm (pashtun wa tajik) baham zindagi darnd wa qomandanani shan Mula Ezat (Tajik), Mula Jaj Mohammad (Tajik), Anwari Dangar (Pashtun) wa Sofi Rasool (Pashtun) bodand. Dar dakhili shahri Kabul ki imrooz sowam hissai aan hazara ast, aslan na az kabul astand wa na az atrafi nazdiki kabul. Az afghanistan markazi amada and.
Man khosh daram afghanha az har qawm ki bashad dar har jaai afghanistan ki khwasta bashand zindagi bokonnad. watani shan ast wa bayad kas maani nashawad. Eenha gulani hameen chaman and wa bayad bashand. Man mikhwaham hazara dar qalbi Kandahar, tajik dar qalbi paktya wa paktika wa pashtun dar qalbi badakhsan wa bamiyan zindagi kunand. Bayad bokonand, zira ki har jai watani shan ast. Ba een tareeq har kas kishwar ra az khod midanad wa wahdati mili tameen mishawad. Har adami talimyafta bayad hardo zabani mohimi afghanistan (pashto wa dari) ra bidanad ta ki ta'asob az bain birawad. agar man wa too zabani yakdigar ra bidaneem, digar sababi adami tafahum az bain mirawad. Ma bay ewazi tafraq wa nifaq barai tafahom wa wahdak kar koneem. Hama aqwami afghanistan ghareeb astand; hamagi dar nadari wa jahalat misoozand. Tafahom, rawadari, wa gozasht mara nazdeek karda metawanad. Een wazifai har afghani shareef ast. Een kharijiha astand ki mi goyand ki too zyad khordi wa ma kam. Dar haliki na too cheezi khordi wa na man.
Agar dar goftari man cheezi khoshi tan amad begereed wa anki khoshi taan nayamad mara ba karami khod bibakhsheed wa motawajeh bishazeed ki man ensan astam wa sahwa mikonam.
Ba arzi hormat.

________________________________________
From: elias-12@hotmail.de
To: farouqazam@hotmail.com
Subject: RE: Salam
Date: Fri, 27 Aug 2010 11:37:25 +0200

Doctor sahib muhtaram salam,

sobat tan sherin ast wa tashakur az mahlumate ke daadin. Ama jak chiz ra man baz pursam meekardum in ke shuma nazar ba kundam taarikh kabul we herat ra share pashtun neshin sefat kardeend wa nazar be kudam ehsaia shuma safahate shaml afghansitan ra 40% pashtun esab kardeen. beradar hai pashtun ma berader masst ama nazar ba tarikhe watan maa (Kabulistan) hamesha farsi zaban buda wa ast, herate kuhan markaze zaban farsi buda wa ast, metawaneed kame tashri bedi? Afghan hai ma ke dar kharej astand har che ra baawar mekunand ama in ba nazare man haqiqat nadarad wa ba nazare watandarane ma khudai naakhaasta be etelahti shuma ra dar nazar watandaran jelwa meta. shuma name khuda jak shaksiat buzurg asteen wa inke pashtun, tajik, hazara, usbek hindu bajad haqiqat ra benawisand wa tabaqa jawan mara mahlumat nan durust nadehand ke gunai buzurg ast, khususan kase ke da watan nabuda ham chiz ra bawar mekunad

Tashakur az lutfe tan wa khuda hafiz

________________________________________
From: farouqazam@hotmail.com
To: elias-12@hotmail.de
Subject: RE: Salam
Date: Tue, 24 Aug 2010 19:11:12 +0100

Biradar mohtarm Eliasjan, salam
Man ba shuma ziyad Ekhtilaf nadaram. Waqti watani to dar wa diwar ra az dast dad, har kas wa na kas wa har janawar daran dakhil mishawad. Hatta watan ki rahbar wa hokomati khob nadashta bashad misli deeg ki sarposh nadashta bashad; khas wa khashak wa magas az hawa daran dakhil mishawad. Awal, awladi salehi watan ki khana ra az khod midanad, bayad ba khanai khod dar wa diwar joor konand ta payi har begana wa sag wa sagoor qata shawad.
Ehtiram

________________________________________
From: elias-12@hotmail.de
To: farouqazam@hotmail.com
Subject: RE: Salam
Date: Tue, 24 Aug 2010 17:13:23 +0200

Doctor saheb muhtaram salam,

humid ast ke hamrai famile muhtaram khub baashed. Feker meekunum ke gharbi ha ba afghanistan hamla nakardand balke mardume afghanistan, zan, mard wa tefel afgh ra as dast pakistani ha, arab ha, chechenia nejat dadand. man tafawet hamla amrica ra ba iraq ba afgh muqaesa karda nametawanum. marde 20 sala almani az daste taleban wa pakistani hai washi dar watan man kushte mesha. Durust ast ke gharbi ha doste maa nestand, ama dar masalae afghanistan az Pakistan, Iran, Saudi karda ba maa khuband.

roze khush ba shuma arezo medarum

________________________________________
From: farouqazam@hotmail.com
To: elias-12@hotmail.de
Subject: RE: Salam
Date: Wed, 18 Aug 2010 15:52:29 +0100

Biradari mosafir man, iliasjan.
Az namai por mohabati tan tashakur. Man az harakati baddi hech kas defaa namikunam wa na khwaham kard. ولا تزر وازرة وزر اخریWali bayad motawajeh basheem har chezi ki gharb megoyad sahih neest.
Baayad motawajeh basheem ki gharb qarnha qodrati estimari boda wa kishwarhai asia wa afrika ra zeer tasaloti khod dasht ast. Wa een tasalot ra tawasuti zoor, dorogh, fareb wa ghadar amali karda. Imroz media (tv, radio, akhbar, majallah,…) yak aslahai qawi dar dasti enha ast wa maghz mara misazad. Choon ma bidooni tv, radio wa akhbari enha digar manbai khabar nadarim, mojbooreem ba enha gosh deheem wa raji ba ma doroghhai shan ra bishnaweem. Bazi awqat dorogh namigoyand, wali, haqayeq ra tahreef mekonand ki een az dorogh badtar ast.
Enha dar watni khod democracy darand wa kar ra ba asasi liyaqat wa ahliyat ba kas medihad. Dar taqaror qawm, zaban wa samt brayishan matrah neest. Kar ba ahal miseparand. Wali dar watani ma ki mi ayand, karhara ba dozd, qachaqbar, qatil, … meedihad. Wa ma ra ba qawm, zaban, mazhab wa samt taqseem mekonad. Ba ma fikar medihad ki shoma hamma khordeed wa doshmani sari ma asteed wa ba shoma megoyad ki man hamma khordom wa doshmani shoma astam. Mara ba yak nam wa shomara ba nami digar tapa mezanad. Dar haliki na man chezi khordom wa na shoma. Balki hama dar mosibat yasan hasteem. Sari ma qabool karda ki ma wa khodit bad wa enha khoob astand.
Ma bayad ba khod biyayeem. Man tora dar aghosh begiram wa shom mara.
Ehtram

________________________________________
From: elias-12@hotmail.de
To: farouqazam@hotmail.com
Subject: RE: Salam
Date: Wed, 18 Aug 2010 13:46:55 +0200

Salam Doctor saheb mohtaram.

khuda nakhasta bashad ke man jak hamwatan khude dashnaam bedeham wa ja kafir begoim. ma ba ham berader asteem wa eftekhare maasti. Man da germany astam wa ar roz ke dar afghansitan chize rukh bata (bini zane afghan ra buridan ja 10 doctor ra kala buridand) dar daftar man bajad az afghanistan defah kunam wali mesharmam ba his afgh az in harakat, raftar wa kedare islam garaian dar afghanistan. Az taleb nafrin daram, chun islam wa mazhab ma ra dar nazde gharbi ha wahshi, adam khush, terrorist jelwa dadand, jak laktahe bad nami ba islam astand.

khuda hafiz wa nasir shuma

________________________________________
From: farouqazam@hotmail.com
To: elias-12@hotmail.de
Subject: RE: Salam
Date: Tue, 17 Aug 2010 13:34:38 +0100

My brother Eliasjan, salam
Har qadar doshnam bedihi wa mara kafir khitab koni, ma shoma ra brother mikhwanam.
Biradari bozorgi shoma

کفری چو منی ګزاف و اسان نبود محکمتر از ایمان من ایمان نبود
در همه دهر چون منی یک و ان هم کافر پس درهمه دهر یک مسلمان نبود

ابن سیناء بلخی

________________________________________
From: elias-12@hotmail.de
To: farouqazam@hotmail.com
Subject: RE: Salam
Date: Mon, 16 Aug 2010 17:37:24 +0200

Salam Doctor saheb Muhtaram,

I think the azaras, tajiks, Usbezk, Hindus are peaceful and respect other religion, languages, ethics. But for the pashtuns you are either pashtun or “Kafir” like arab or hajam.

khuda hafiz

________________________________________

From: farouqazam@hotmail.com
To: elias-12@hotmail.de
Subject: RE: Salam
Date: Mon, 16 Aug 2010 15:17:12 +0100

I respect your view.
As I mentioned in my writing on National Unity that all ethnic groups in Afghanistan are shareef and flowers of this beautiful garden. No one is better than another. We all are fingers of one hand. If one finger is in pain the others will feel painful unless senseless.
Best wishes

________________________________________

From: elias-12@hotmail.de
To: farouqazam@hotmail.com
Subject: Salam
Date: Mon, 16 Aug 2010 13:21:50 +0200

Salam Aghai Dr saheb azam,

tashakur az maqala jalebe tan dar azmoone melli. Chand sawali ba man khalq shud ke az shum uhtaram pursan kunum:

1. Herat wa kabul az tarikh wa aknun parsi zaban dudand wa astand. dar kabul tanha forma hai daulati pashto bud wa pashtun wa pashtu sharm ba ehali kabul bud.
2. Nazar ba kundam dalil wa sanad shuma nofuse pashtun hara dar shamale afghanistan ba 40% tahin namudeed? In pashtun hai kuji maqsad maa neest.
3. Feker mekuned ke tanha qaum qabael jangjo wa dleer astand wa aquam digar afhanistan tarso wa bozdel.
Dr. saheb shuma bajad aadelaana sobat kuneed wa aqua digar afgh harkudamsh sheer bacha astand wa pashtun ha kudam bartari az aquam digar nadarand.
Chera betarafane wa adelana sobat nemekuned? Waqte ke pashtune pakistani az tajeke afghani ba pashun wa aughana peshter bashand, pas afghanistan che. man tajik astam wa ba iran wa tejekistan aslan allqa nadarm. afghaiszan watan man ast wa jak berdaer pashtun ba man nazdik ast nazar ba jak irani, ja tajeki tajekistan. Ba Pashun ha bedune dar nazar dasht sisat mula omar, tanai, haqani, karzai, gulbuddin jak shachs astand. man awal afghan astam bad, musalman bad tajik. jak pashtun awal pashtun ast, bad pshtun ast baz pashtun ast, bad musalman bad aughan.

Ta che waq maktab sozaani, mahlem kushi, gardan buridan? Shuma fazle khuda musalman sateen dar in roze ramazn chera aquam digar afghanistan ra haqeb mezaneed.
Dar har familie pashtun jak taleb ast wa hama taleb ha pashtum astnad walau agar dar mazare sharif, kunduz ja qandahr bashand. haqeb manda, bar zede kultur, rasem wa rawaj afghnistan wa hamesh " walah che peredem".

khuda hafiz wa nasere tan

Samim Tawana
08.09.2010

پتنګ صیب که ددې خوندور ډیالوګ لنډ مفهوم ولیکې ښه به وي.
ځکه دومره حوصله به څوک ونلري چې دا ډیالوګ له سره تر پایه ولولي.
که په پښتو توریو لیکل شوی وه بیا یو څه کیدل. خو په انګریزي حروفو پښتو سړی خسته کوي.

31.10.2010

د ډاکتر صيب د ځوابونو او اندتوګې سره که څوک موافق نه وي ودې وايي چې ولې او په څشي کې ور سره يو نظر نه لري . که څوک اوس
خپ و چوپ کښيني او وروسته بيادملي وحدت په اړه داسې نظر څرګندوي چې ته وا دډاکتر صيب له نظر څخه يې نه يواځې هېڅ نه دي اخيستي، بلکې ١٨٠ درجې ضديت ورسره لري (!).

سر بېره په دې دغه بحث له کوم ويبسايت څخه راخيستل شوی ، د ګران پتنګ ياد دې په خير وي ، بايد لېنک هم ورکړی وای . په هر صورت
د سفر ښې ، نيکمرغې او موفقې شپې ورځې ورته غواړو !